The sentence ‘He has never been heard from since he left for Alaska’ might be confusing when you look at it from the perspective of passive voice and subject placement. Let’s break it down to understand why ‘He’ is the subject and not ‘him’ in this case.
What is the Meaning of ‘He has never been heard from’?
In English, the phrase ‘to hear from someone’ means to receive communication or contact from that person. When we say ‘He has never been heard from’, it means that nobody has received any communication from him. This construction is in the passive voice, where ‘He’ (the person who has not communicated) is the subject of the sentence.
Why ‘He’ is Used Instead of ‘Him’
In the sentence ‘He has never been heard from’, the subject ‘He’ is in the nominative case because it is the subject of the passive verb ‘has been heard’. Even though the action (hearing from) is being performed by others, ‘He’ is the focus of the sentence. In passive voice, the subject receives the action, even if it’s an action done by others (in this case, someone else is doing the hearing). In contrast, ‘him’ is the accusative form, which is used when the person is the object of an action.
Can You Use ‘I’ve never heard from him’ Instead?
Yes, ‘I’ve never heard from him’ is also grammatically correct, but the difference lies in the perspective of the speaker. In this sentence, ‘I’ (the speaker) is the subject who is doing the hearing. However, in the original sentence, the focus is on ‘He’—the one who is not being heard from. This subtle shift in focus explains why ‘He’ is used in the original example while ‘him’ would be used if the speaker is the subject.
Understanding Passive Voice and Its Effect on Sentence Structure
The use of the passive voice in this sentence makes it clear that the focus is on the subject who is not doing the action, but rather receiving the action. When using passive voice, the subject often becomes the one who is affected by the action, which is why ‘He’ is appropriate in this case. If the sentence were in active voice, it would sound like ‘I have never heard from him,’ where ‘I’ is the active subject performing the action.
Conclusion: Is ‘He’ or ‘Him’ Correct?
The key takeaway is that in passive voice, the subject is the one receiving the action, which is why ‘He’ is used in ‘He has never been heard from.’ If you shift to active voice, ‘him’ would be used because it would then function as the object of the verb. Understanding these nuances between active and passive voice helps in using pronouns correctly in different contexts.
コメント