In this article, we’ll explore why the sentence ‘He is a good writer in that’ is correct, while ‘He is a good writer that’ is not. Understanding the proper use of ‘in that’ versus ‘that’ can help improve your writing skills and avoid common grammatical mistakes.
1. The Correct Usage of ‘in that’
The phrase ‘in that’ is used to introduce a reason or explanation for something. In the sentence ‘He is a good writer in that he has an elegant style,’ the phrase ‘in that’ introduces the explanation of why the writer is considered good: his elegant style. This structure is grammatically correct and commonly used in English to provide reasoning.
‘In that’ functions as a conjunction to connect two clauses, explaining a specific characteristic or reason related to the subject of the sentence.
2. Why ‘He is a good writer that’ is Incorrect
The phrase ‘that’ is a relative pronoun, used to introduce relative clauses that describe or specify a noun. However, in the sentence ‘He is a good writer that he has an elegant style,’ ‘that’ is used incorrectly. It implies a relative clause, but the structure doesn’t call for one. The sentence becomes awkward and grammatically incorrect.
While ‘that’ can often be used in relative clauses, it does not work in this context where an explanation or reason is needed. The use of ‘that’ in this sentence would result in confusion, as it doesn’t properly link the clauses in the way ‘in that’ does.
3. The Difference Between ‘in that’ and ‘that’
Understanding the difference between ‘in that’ and ‘that’ is crucial for clear and correct communication. ‘In that’ is used to provide an explanation or justification for something, whereas ‘that’ introduces relative clauses that add extra information about a noun.
For example, ‘She is clever in that she can solve any problem quickly’ provides a reason why she is considered clever. On the other hand, ‘The book that I read was interesting’ uses ‘that’ to describe which book is being referred to.
4. Common Mistakes with ‘in that’ and ‘that’
Many English learners mistakenly use ‘that’ when they should use ‘in that’ because both words seem similar. However, understanding their distinct roles will help you avoid these errors. ‘In that’ requires a specific explanation or reason, while ‘that’ should be used to introduce a descriptive relative clause.
To remember the difference, always ask yourself: Are you giving an explanation (use ‘in that’), or describing something (use ‘that’)?
Conclusion
In conclusion, ‘He is a good writer in that’ is correct because it gives an explanation, while ‘He is a good writer that’ is incorrect because ‘that’ doesn’t serve the right grammatical function. By understanding the proper usage of ‘in that’ versus ‘that,’ you’ll enhance your writing and avoid common mistakes in your English sentences.
コメント