In English, prepositions play an important role in connecting verbs to their objects. The sentence ‘They spoke each other’ is incorrect, while ‘They spoke to each other’ is grammatically correct. In this article, we will explain why the first sentence is wrong and why the second one works. We will also provide examples to help clarify the difference.
The Role of Prepositions in English
In English, prepositions like ‘to’, ‘with’, and ‘at’ are used to show relationships between actions and objects. When you use certain verbs, such as ‘speak’, you must choose the correct preposition to make the sentence grammatically correct. A preposition determines how the action (verb) relates to the subject and the object.
In the case of ‘speak’, the correct preposition is ‘to’ when talking about communication between two people. This is why ‘They spoke to each other’ is correct, while ‘They spoke each other’ is not.
Understanding ‘Speak to’ and ‘Speak with’
The phrase ‘speak to’ is used when one person is talking to another. It implies that the action is directed towards someone, as in ‘She spoke to him.’ This is a common way of expressing communication between people. For example, ‘They spoke to each other’ means that both people communicated with each other.
On the other hand, ‘speak with’ can also be used, and it implies a more mutual conversation or exchange. For example, ‘They spoke with each other’ suggests that both people were actively engaged in the conversation. However, ‘speak each other’ does not make sense, as ‘each other’ is not functioning correctly in the sentence.
Why ‘They spoke each other’ is Incorrect
The phrase ‘They spoke each other’ is incorrect because ‘each other’ is a reciprocal pronoun used to describe an action between two people. However, it needs to follow a verb that can convey mutual action. In English, verbs like ‘help’ or ‘see’ can work with ‘each other’, but ‘speak’ requires the preposition ‘to’ or ‘with’ to form a grammatically correct sentence.
‘They spoke each other’ is also incorrect because there is no direct link between the verb ‘speak’ and the reciprocal pronoun ‘each other’ in this context. The sentence structure is incomplete and does not reflect the proper usage of ‘speak’ in English grammar.
Correct Examples
Here are some correct examples of sentences using ‘speak to’ and ‘speak with’:
- ‘They spoke to each other about their plans.’
- ‘They spoke with each other for hours.’
- ‘He spoke to her about the project.’
In each of these examples, the prepositions ‘to’ or ‘with’ are used correctly to convey communication between people. These prepositions help link the action of speaking with the intended recipient of the speech.
Conclusion
In summary, ‘They spoke each other’ is incorrect because ‘speak’ requires the use of a preposition like ‘to’ or ‘with’ when referring to communication between people. The correct form is ‘They spoke to each other’ or ‘They spoke with each other’, depending on the context of the conversation. Understanding the role of prepositions in English grammar is crucial for constructing clear and correct sentences.
コメント