The question about the sentence ‘Many people took the study as being true’ asks why the word ‘being’ is used when the sentence would still make sense without it. Let’s break it down and explore the grammatical reasons behind this usage.
Understanding the Sentence Structure
The sentence in question is: ‘Many people took the study as being true.’ This sentence involves the verb ‘took,’ which is followed by a noun phrase (‘the study’) and an adjective (‘true’). Normally, we would expect the sentence to be something like ‘Many people took the study as true.’ So, why is ‘being’ included?
The Role of ‘Being’ in the Sentence
‘Being’ in this context is a present participle, functioning as a linking verb between the noun (‘study’) and the adjective (‘true’). It emphasizes the ongoing or continuous state of the study being perceived as true. It adds a subtle nuance to the sentence, highlighting the perception of the study as something actively in the state of being true at the time.
Without ‘being,’ the sentence would still be grammatically correct: ‘Many people took the study as true.’ However, the use of ‘being’ adds a layer of meaning that emphasizes the dynamic aspect of the study’s truth.
How ‘Being’ Changes the Meaning
Using ‘being’ in this case can subtly shift the meaning of the sentence. ‘Being true’ suggests a more continuous or inherent state of truth, rather than a static one. This is a subtle distinction, but it helps convey the perception of the study as actively and continuously valid in the eyes of the people mentioned.
Conclusion
In summary, while ‘being’ is not strictly necessary for the sentence to be understood, it adds an important layer of meaning. The word ‘being’ emphasizes the perception of the study as continuously true, and while the sentence is still grammatically correct without it, the inclusion of ‘being’ helps to clarify the ongoing nature of the study’s truth as perceived by the people.
コメント