In this article, we will discuss how indirect questions work in English, with a focus on how to form them correctly and why certain changes in word order occur. The examples below are commonly encountered in English language learning and will help clarify some common misconceptions.
1. What is an Indirect Question?
An indirect question is a type of question that is embedded within another statement or question. It typically does not use the direct question word order, and instead, the word order follows that of a declarative sentence. Let’s examine the first example:
- There is no reason for my refusing to do it. – In this case, ‘refusing’ is treated as a noun phrase, making the sentence a declarative sentence.
So, an indirect question usually looks like a statement rather than a direct question.
2. Why is ‘What is in that box?’ written as ‘I wonder what is in that box’?
In the case of the sentence ‘I wonder what is in that box’, it may seem like the word order ‘what is’ is incorrect, but this is actually the correct word order for indirect questions. When a sentence starts with a phrase like ‘I wonder’, ‘I know’, or ‘I wonder if’, the verb generally follows the subject, not the question word order. Hence, we say ‘I wonder what is in that box’, instead of ‘I wonder what is in that box’.
This structure is common in indirect questions, and it’s important to understand that these questions are embedded in a larger sentence, which changes the word order.
3. The Use of ‘What Food’ in Questions
In indirect questions such as ‘I wonder what food they like’, ‘what’ acts as the question word, and it remains in its natural position in the sentence. The important thing to note here is that indirect questions do not use auxiliary verbs like ‘do’ or ‘does’ unless the sentence structure requires it (e.g., ‘I wonder what they do’).
The sentence ‘I wonder what food they like’ keeps the same subject-verb order as a statement. This is one of the key differences between direct and indirect questions.
4. Why is ‘There is no knowing where to go’ phrased that way?
In sentences like ‘There is no knowing where to go’, the structure makes it clear that it is not a direct question. It is a phrase expressing uncertainty. The verb ‘knowing’ is followed by the object ‘where to go’, making the phrase sound more like a statement than a question.
Understanding this difference can help clarify why word order might look unusual. English language learners should pay close attention to the word order in indirect questions and recognize when the sentence changes structure due to the embedding of the question.
Conclusion: Mastering Indirect Questions in English
Indirect questions can be tricky for English learners, but once you understand the basic rules of word order and sentence structure, they become much easier to navigate. Remember, indirect questions are part of a larger statement and follow the same word order as a declarative sentence, not a direct question. By practicing with examples like ‘I wonder what is in that box’ and ‘I wonder what food they like’, you’ll be able to grasp these concepts more effectively.
コメント